This trophy no longer exists at the Club. Additional information about this trophy and missing results would be appreciated.
The plaque is missing on the 3rd Place cup – these results are all lost.
| YEAR | 1st Place | 2nd Place | 3rd Place |
| 1958 | George Fisher | – | – |
| 1959 | George Fisher | – | – |
| 1960 | George Fisher | – | – |
| 1961 | George Fisher | Jud Ortman | – |
| 1962 | George Fisher | Jay Limbaugh | – |
| 1963 | George Fisher | Tom Davis | – |
| 1964 | George Fisher | Bob Mann | – |
| 1965 | George Fisher | Jim Dressel | – |
| 1966 | – | – | – |
| 1967 | Marty Headlee | – | – |
| 1968 | – | – | – |
| 1969 | Jim Dressel | – | – |
| 1970 | – | – | – |
| 1971 | – | – | – |
| 1972 | Matt Fisher | Charles Moyer | – |
| 1973 | Ed Metzgar II | Charles Moyer | – |
| 1974 | Dan Roshon | Charles Moyer | – |
| 1975 | Willy Petersilge | Lonn Moyer | – |
| 1976 | Bob Hudgins | Willy Petersilge | – |
| 1977 | Willy Petersilge | Steve Beeson | – |
| 1978 | Willy Petersilge | Lonn Moyer | – |
| 1979 | Mike Hein II | Walter Grubb | – |
| 1980 | Dan Dressel | Russ Crist | – |
| 1981 | Matt Fisher | Tom Eisert | – |
| 1982 | – | – | – |
| 1983 | Mike Hein II | Tami Headlee | – |